Deviations in Water Quality Data for the Monterey Bay Aquarium Sea Otter Display
Charles J. Farwell, Curator; Tom Williams, DVM; Julie Hymer, Aquarist
The water quality control system designed for the Monterey Bay Aquarium
Sea Otter display consists of re-circulating display water through a pair of high-pressure
sandfilters at a rate of 500 gpm and through an ultra-violet sterilizing unit rated at a maximum
flow of 800 gpm. Return water quality is monitored weekly for coliform content and routinely
measures coliform bacteria at less than 2 MPN (most probable number). Incoming or new seawater
is added continuously to the display at a rate of 250 gpm, the measured coliform content for MBA
intake water is also less than 2 MPN. Surface skimming removes water from the system at a rate
equal to the incoming new water.
The combined flow of these two systems is calculated to be 750 gpm which
give a theoretical turn over once every 1.1 hours for the 50,000 gallon display. Weekly analysis
for coliform content of the display water were started in October 1984, when the display first
received three sea otters. The results from the early coliform water tests indicated that a
potential problem existed in water quality control. On three separate occasions, one each in
January, March and June 1985, coliform counts between 1000-2400 MPN were received. (Maximum
allowable coliforms not to exceed 1000 MPN, USDA regulations). In spite of weekly cleaning by
draining and hosing the tank down with seawater and physically removing all remaining food
particles and organic debris, coliform counts as high as 2400 MPN were being reported. To better
understand the problem, a brief description of the display tank is needed.
The display is 15.3 feet deep and 29 feet long and 23 feet wide at its
widest points and has a water volume of approximately 50,000 gallons. The backwalls and portions
of the bottom of the display are covered with artificial rockwork. In addition to the artificial
rockwork, large boulders cover the sub-flooring, a fiberglass grate which extends over the
bottom and is raised four inches from the actual bottom surface. Two conical shaped floor drains
lead to the filter-sterilization system. Incoming and return water is added through manifold
system designed to mix the water and created a circular current.
Due to our desire to raise subtidal kelp and algae in the otter exhibit
direct cleaning of the rock surfaces was restricted to seawater sprayed onto the rockwork. The
development of an algal turf on the rock surfaces did not succeed. Diatoms, filamentous algae
and some red algae did grow but were not considered desirable.
Several theories exist to why we were experiencing water quality problems;
the addition of a fourth otter in the summer of 1985; high food consumption, 14-18% of their
combined body weights; and the possible retention of coliform. Type bacteria on the algal mat
and rock surfaces were considered as potential contributing factors.
The extent of the problem did not become known until spring of 1986. The
weekly test reports in March and continuing through June exceeded the maximum concentration
allowed by the USDA. Reports of 1600-9200 MPN being common in spite of daily cleaning and
refilling the display. At this time the combined weights of the four display sea otters was 167
lbs and they were eating 24 lbs per day of food or 14.4% of their body weight.
During the period of time that the coliform counts were exceeding the
maximum allowable number the return water was being tested and continued to be less than two
coliform MPN. In spite of filtration-sterilization the coliforms counts continued to increase.
The original water system design took into account the organic and bacterial load that would be
encountered in keeping four adult sea otters in a display of this size. Additional contributing
factors were examined.
A theory that the high coliform counts were directly related to the algal
mat was proposed. A new tank cleaning procedure where sodium hypochlorite, 12.5% active
chlorine, was sprayed onto all rock surfaces and left for several hours to re-act with the
organic coating. The tank was then washed down with a high pressure hose, the chlorine
neutralized and the tank drained, re-filled and flushed overnight. This procedure resulted in
lowering the coliform counts to levels well below the maximum allowable number.
This procedure was modified from direct spraying of sodium hypochlorite to
adding it directly into the display tank water. Thirty gallons of 12.5% active chlorine solution
is added and allowed to circulate through the entire system including the sand filters. The
concentration of chlorine is calculated to be approximately 30 ppm. After a two hour exposure
time, the chlorine is neutralized with sodium thiosulfate, the tank emptied, hosed out with a
high pressure hose, rinsed and then re-filled. The sea otters are returned to the exhibit the
following morning. This procedure has been in effect since June 1986, on three occasions during
the next year, or 3 out of 52 weekly water samples, coliform counts exceeded 1000 MPN. Between
June 1987 and March 1988 four coliform samples exceeded 1000 MPN. During this last period of
time, October through March, the cleaning schedule was modified from weekly to Bi-weekly as a
test.
It is interesting to note that the high coliform counts for the last three
years have occurred during early spring. It is during this time period that the Sea otter
display starts receiving extra sunlight and nutrient levels as the incoming seawater increases.
Consequently, it is during this time period when we first notice a sharp increase in diatom and
filamentous algae growth, a time marked by increased sunlight and increased nutrient levels in
the incoming seawater.