Can Blind Monk Seals Help Us See?
IAAAM Archive
Myra Blanchard1, MS, MT; Brian Aldridge1,2, PhD,
DACVIM, MRCVS; Christina Funke1, MS; Don King1, PhD; Tracey
Goldstein1,2, BA; Frances Gulland2, VetMB, PhD, MRCVS; George
Antonelis3, PhD; A. Alonso Aguirre4, DVM, PhD; Robert Braun5,
DVM, PhD; John Reif6, MS, DVM; Les Dalton7, DVM; Sherry
Dickerson7, BS; Jeff Stott1, PhD
1Laboratory for Marine Mammal Immunology, School of Vet. Med.
University of California, Davis, CA, USA; 2The Marine Mammal Center, Marin Headlands,
Sausalito, CA, USA; 3National Marine Fisheries Service, Honolulu, HI, USA;
4Center for Conservation Medicine, Tufts School of Vet. Med., North Grafton, MA, USA;
5Dolphin Quest, Kohala, HI, USA; 6Department of Environmental Health,
College of Vet. Med., Colorado State University, Ft Collins, CO, USA; 7SeaWorld of
Texas, San Antonio, TX, USA
Abstract
In marine mammal health science we are confronted with a number of threatened and declining
populations. There is an urgent need to investigate the contribution of disease and loss of genetic diversity to these
declines. Unfortunately, efforts to address the health status are often impaired by inability to access biologic samples.
Hawaiian Monk Seals have been on the endangered species list since 1975, yet like many species, knowledge about them is
limited. A group of 10 seals were awaiting release from rehabilitation when some developed ocular lesions and became
blind; the cause is still unknown. These animals were considered unfit for release and are currently housed at Sea World
of San Antonio. Here they help to educate the public about their fragile status. But can we better utilize this precious
resource?
With a goal of assay development focusing on genetics and health assessment, a concerted and
collaborative effort was initiated to maximize the scientific information obtained utilizing samples recently collected
from these 10 captive seals during routine health evaluation in February 2000. Assay parameters were evaluated while
simultaneously gaining knowledge about monk seal genetics, disease exposure and basic and immunologic health.
The genes of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC class I and II) were chosen for monk seal
genotyping. The variability and immunologic importance of the genes in this complex makes these ideal candidates for
identifying parental lineage, evaluating genetic diversity and predicting susceptibility to specific pathogens.
Preliminary data were generated from a cDNA library, which was constructed from peripheral blood mononuclear leukocyte
RNA. Full-length MHC genes were sequenced and primers developed for rapid genotyping using a technique that combines
polymerase chain reaction (PCR), denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE), and direct automated sequencing. These
data lay the foundation to access immunologically pertinent genetic information on both archived and fresh samples.
Assay development related to health assessment was multifaceted. Efforts were made to evaluate
immunologic health via leukocyte phenotyping and lymphocyte function. Leukocyte phenotyping was approached utilizing
analytic flow cytometry and a variety of reagents developed for other species. By identifying cross-reactive reagents, we
were able to establish absolute numbers of peripheral blood T and B lymphocytes, thus generating hematologic data that
will augment traditional measurements. Evaluation of lymphocyte function was approached with a lymphocyte blastogenesis
(stimulation) assay as it can be adapted to all species. Cryopreserved monk seal mononuclear leukocytes collected during
the health assessment were employed in the titration of mitogen concentrations and incubation times in order to adapt a
mitogen-based blastogenesis approach that we developed for identification of cetacean immune system dysfunction.
Information about past disease exposure was gather by employing ELISA technology. An anti-grey seal
IgG monoclonal antibody, shown to bind harbor seal, elephant seal and monk seal IgG with high affinity, was used as a
secondary antibody. Previous exposure to herpesvirus was evaluated by looking for cross-reacting serum antibodies to
Phocine herpesvirus-1 (PHV-1). One animal was found to react in this assay and suggests exposure to a PHV-1 related
organism. Nasal swabs collected in February 2000 are being analyzed by PCR for evidence of current viral shedding.
Serum from eight of the ten seals during the health assessment was used in a B9 bioassay to look for
evidence of interleukin-6 (IL-6) production. This cytokine increases dramatically during the initial stages of acute
inflammation and appears earlier in the process than other inflammatory mediators, such as fibrinogen. No serum IL-6 was
detected, nor were any of the classic mediators of inflammation. The IL-6 bioassay is being further validated for use in
the Monk seals using cryopreserved leukocytes as a source of cytokine.
Development/identification of many useful reagents, optimization and validation of a variety of assays
and acquisition of baseline data will assist in management of both captive and wild populations, while reducing response
time in addressing problems. In conclusion, the scientific insight gained from these blind animals should remind us of the
importance of maximizing sampling opportunities for this and other endangered species.