The most common conditions that can be treated effectively with acupuncture include osteoarthritis (OA), degenerative joint disease (DJD) and pain.1-6 In Traditional Chinese Veterinary Medicine (TCVM), OA, DJD and painful clinical conditions are considered as Bi syndrome (stiffness and pain). It can be divided into 6 types: Wind Bi, Cold Bi, Damp Bi, Heat Bi, Kidney Yang Deficiency Bone Bi and Kidney Yin/Qi Deficiency Bone Bi. This presentation will focus on how to select acupuncture points and techniques for treatment of these 6 types of osteoarthritis in dogs and cats.7-10
I. Wind Bi Syndrome
Also called wandering Bi (Xing Bi)
Etiology and Signs
Wind-Cold-Damp (but Wind dominant) invasion into the exterior
Wind obstructs Qi-Blood flow in muscle, bone and meridian
Rapid onset, pain in meridian and joints
Changing from one place to another ("pain wanders")
Pain worsens when exposed to Wind
Tongue: slightly thin and pale coating
Pulse: superficial (floating)
Treatment Strategy
Eliminate Wind and invigorate the channels
Eliminate Cold and disperse Damp
Acupuncture Points
GB-20: Pond of Wind. Eliminate Wind and clear the exterior
Bl-17: Influential point of Blood. Invigorate and activate Blood
Sp-10: Sea of Blood. Invigorate and activate Blood
LIV: Invigorate Qi in order to eliminate stagnation and eliminate Wind
Local points or A-shi points: Move local Qi and resolve stagnation and pain
Herbal Formula: Fang Feng Tang (Siler Powder)
II. Cold Bi Syndrome
Also called Painful Bi (Tong Bi)
Etiology and Signs
Wind-Cold-Damp (but Cold dominant) invasion into joints
Coldness obstructs Qi and Blood flow
Pain in joints, difficulty in movement (acute)
Pain relieves when exposed to heat
Pain exacerbates when exposed to Cold
Tongue: purple with a pale coating
Pulse: Tight and wiry
Treatment Strategy
Warm the Channel and eliminate Cold
Eliminate Wind-Damp
Acupuncture Treatment
Using moxibustion or electro-acupuncture
Shen-shu and BL-23: kidney association point, and Warm Yang and eliminate Cold
Bai-hui: Warm Yang and strengthen kidney
GV-4: Warm Yang and eliminate Cold
Combined with local points or A-shi points: Move local Qi and resolve stagnation and pain
Herbal Formula One: Dok's Formula (Du Huo Ji Sheng Tang)
III. Damp Bi Syndrome
Also called Fixed Bi (Zuo Bi)
Etiology and Signs
Wind-Cold-Damp (but Damp dominant) invasion into joints
Damp obstruct Qi and Blood flow
Difficulty in movement (chronic); more stiffness than pain
Pain relieves when exposed to heat and dryness
Pain exacerbates when exposed to Cold-Damp (weather changed)
Tongue: greasy with a pale coating
Pulse: soft and slow
Treatment Strategy
Resolve Damp and activate channel
Eliminate Wind-Cold
Acupuncture Treatment
SP-6: Strengthen spleen and resolve Damp
SP-9: Strengthen spleen and resolve Damp
ST-36: Strengthen spleen and resolve Damp
Local points or A-shi points: Move local Qi and resolve stagnation and pain
Herbal Formula: Coix Formula (Yi Yi Ren Tang)
IV. Heat Bi Syndrome
Also called Febrile Bi (Re Bi)
Etiology and Signs
Wind-Damp-Heat (but Heat dominant) invasion into joints, muscles and meridians
Pain, redness, swelling and heat of joints, infectious arthritis
Acute onset; fever or thirst
Tongue: red with yellow coating
Pulse: strong and fast
Treatment Strategy
Clear Heat and activate Channels
Eliminate Wind-Damp
Acupuncture Treatment
GV-14: clear Heat and eliminate Wind, invigorate Yang, Qi-Blood
LI-11: clear Wind-Heat and resolve swelling
LI-4: clear Wind-Heat
ST-44: clear Heat
Local points or A-shi points: Move local Qi and resolve stagnation and pain
Herbal Formula: Bai Hu Si Miao Tang
V. Kidney Yang Deficiency Bone Bi Syndrome
Also called bony Bi (gu bi). Including hip dysplasia.
Etiology and Signs
Kidney Yang Deficiency fails to support bone, back and knees
Difficulty in getting up, walking
Coldness in back and extremities, or soft stool
Lameness worse in Cold/Damp; heat-seeking
Tongue: pale and wet
Pulse: deep and weak
Treatment Strategy
Tonify Kidney Yang
Eliminate Wind-Cold-Damp
Acupuncture Treatment
Bai-hui: warm Kidney Yang and strengthen back
Jian-jiao (#124): Hip dysplasia point in dog
BL-23: Tonify Kidney
BL 11: Influential point of bones and strengthens bones
BL 40: Strengthen lower back and hind limbs
BL 60: Aspirin point and disperse Wind and relaxes muscles
GB-34: Influential point for tendons, ligaments and bones
GB-39: Influential point for bone marrow
Herbal Formula One: Loranthus Powder (Sang-ji-sheng)
VI. Kidney Yin and Qi Deficiency (Bone Steaming)
Etiology and Signs
Kidney Yin Deficiency leads to bone steaming
Arthritis, weak in back and limbs
Infections in discs, spondylitis
Difficulty in getting up, walking
Tongue: pink or pale
Pulse: weak and deep
Treatment Strategy
Tonify Kidney Yin and Yang
Eliminate Wind-Damp
Acupuncture Treatment
KID-3: Nourish Kidney and strengthen lower back
LIV-3: Break up stagnation, nourish liver
SP-9: Strengthens spleen, resolve Damp
SP-6: Nourish kidney, spleen and liver
LI-10/11: Dispels the Surface, tonification of Qi and Blood
ST-36: Tonification of Qi and Blood
Herbal Formula: Di Gu Pi
Combination with the Local Acupoints
1. Neck area: Jing-jia-ji, SI-16, LI-16
2. Shoulder area: LI-14/15, SI-9, TH-14
3. Elbow area: Zhou-shu, LI-10/11, TH-10, LU-5
4. Carpus area: LI-4, SI-3, TH-5
5. Vertebral column: Hua-tuo-jia-ji at the lesion areas, BL-11, GV-14, Bai-hui, Wei-jian
6. Pelvic limb/hind ends: Jian-jiao, Er-yan, BL-54, BL-35, BL-36
7. Coxofemoral area: GB-29/30, BL-54, Hou-tiao/hou/zhong
8. Stifle area: BL-39/40, ST-35a/b, ST-36/34, GB-34/33/32
Conclusion
TCVM therapy including acupuncture and herbal medicine is highly effective for pain management of arthritis patients. Proper exercise and daily massage can enhance the results of acupuncture and herbal medicine.
Table 1. Acupuncture and herbal medicine for treatment of common patterns of arthritis
Pattern
|
Clinical signs
|
Acupuncture points Herbal medicine
|
Painful (Cold) Bi
|
Joint pain, difficult movement, Heat relieves pain Dislikes being massaged; Cold exacerbates pain Tongue: purple or normal; slightly pale coating Pulse: Tight and wiry pulse
|
GV-3/4, Bai-hui, BL-10/26, CV-4, + Local points Dok's Formula
|
Fixed (Damp) Bi
|
Difficult movement, more stiffness than pain Heat and dryness relieves pain Cold-damp (weather changes) exacerbates pain Tongue: Greasy/pale coating Pulse: Soft and slow
|
BL-20/21/22, SP-6/9, ST-40/36, + local points Coix Formula
|
Kidney Qi/Yang Deficiency Bi Syndrome
|
Difficulty getting up and/or walking Coldness of back and extremities or soft stool Lameness is worse in cold/damp or winter Heat seeking, likes to be massaged Tongue: Pale, wet Pulse: Deep and weak
|
GV-3/4, Bai-hui,CV-4/6 (moxa), + local points Loranthus Powder
|
Kidney Yin and Qi/Yang Deficiency Bi Syndrome
|
Dry skin, thirsty Lameness is worse in summer or hot conditions Cool-seeking Difficulty in getting up, lethargy Tongue: Pale or red Pulse: Thready and weak
|
BL-23, SP-6, KID-3/6/7/10Di Gu Pi
|
References
1. Cantwell SL. Traditional Chinese veterinary medicine: the mechanism and management of acupuncture for chronic pain. Topics in Companion Animal Medicine. 2010;25(1):53–58.
2. Suarez-Almazor ME, Looney C, Liu Y, Cox V, Pietz K, Marcus DM, Street RL Jr. A randomized controlled trial of acupuncture for osteoarthritis of the knee: effects of patient-provider communication. Arthritis Care & Research (Hoboken). 2010;62(9):1229–1236.
3. Zhang QR, Fu WB. Osteoarthritis of knee joint treated with acupuncture and moxibustion. Zhongguo Zhen Jiu. 2010;30(5):375–378 [article in Chinese].
4. Molsberger AF, Schneider T, Gotthardt H, Drabik A. German randomized acupuncture trial for chronic shoulder pain (GRASP) - a pragmatic, controlled, patient-blinded, multi-centre trial in an outpatient care environment. Pain. 2010;151(1):146–154.
5. Kenney JD, McCormick WH. Manual therapy, acupuncture, and Chinese herbal medicine in the geriatric equine. In: Equine Geriatric Medicine and Surgery. 2006:79–114.
6. Xie H, Ortiz-Umpierre C. What acupuncture can and cannot treat. Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association. 2006;42(4):244–248.
7. McCauley L, Glinski MH. Acupuncture for veterinary rehabilitation. In: Millis DL, Levine D, Taylor RA, eds. Canine Rehabilitation & Physical Therapy. 2004:337–354.
8. Rychel JK. Diagnosis and treatment of osteoarthritis. Topics in Companion Animal Medicine. 2010;25(1):20–25.
9. Xie H, Preast V. Xie's Veterinary Acupuncture. Ames, IA: Blackwell Publishing; 2007:247–266.
10. Schoen AM. Veterinary Acupuncture Ancient Art to Modern Medicine. 2nd ed. St. Louis, MO: Mosby; 2001:161–178.