Veterinary Hospital Universidad Nacional Autfinoma de México, University of Mexico
Mexico City, Mexico
Aggression is one of the most frequent behavioral problems in dogs; it is a very important public health issue. It is important to keep in mind that any dog can be "potentially" dangerous regardless of breed, environment and learning play a very important role in the development of aggression in dogs, as well as the sociology of the people wanting aggressive animals also plays a major role in the development of the problem.
General information protocol
Aggression is a symptom not a diagnosis
Can not be cured
Could have many causes
Prognosis and treatment are different depending on the type of aggression displayed
Owner directed aggression
Persistent aggression, biting, snapping, growling toward family members
Mostly in competitive contexts
Showing dominant or offensive postures
Generally manifested in a predictable way
Owner directed aggression can occur together with other problems that make its diagnosis and treatment more difficult
Impulsivity and anxiety
Impulsivity means a reduction or a complete lack of warning signals prior to an attack
Impulsivity makes the dog more dangerous and complicates diagnosis, especially because it is difficult for the owners to link the occurrence of aggression episodes to specific situations.
Anxiety
Anxiety postures and typical postures of fear aggression are showed during aggression episodes
Hierarchic conflicts between dogs are quickly resolved and the resulting hierarchy tends to be very stable
However, in the domestic environment owners sometimes behave towards the dog as dominant individuals whereas in other situations they adopt a submissive posture
Aggressive behavior is explained as a defensive behavior in front of and unpleasant situation
Case Report: "Dios" Owner directed aggression
Signalment
Intact male
Pit bull terrier
7 years old
Chief complaint
Aggression towards the male owner
Family
Glicinia (female owner)
Mardo (male owner)
Lola (kitten)
2 male adult dogs in another yard
Maid 2x a week
Occasionally Glicinia's sister and two kids (Glicinia's nieces)
Onset of behaviors
Aggressive behavior was first noticed when Dios was about 2 years old
To Mardo when tried to get Dios off the bed when Glicinia was already in
When Mardo approached Glicinia during her menstrual period
Both incidents were without biting
First biting incident 4 years ago: Glicinia and Dios were in bed, Mardo tried to move Dios to get closer to her and Dios bit him in the hand. Glicinia was able to get Dios off and calm him down.
Most recent biting incident 3 weeks prior to consultation. Glicinia was working at her desk, Dios was sleeping by her side, Mardo approached her and Dios bit him in the ankle, owner reported no warning signals before the bite.
Since the last incident Mardo is afraid of Dios and has stopped all interaction with him, Glicinia reinforces Dios all attention and affection demands, in the house Dios is very sociable and demands attention from anybody including visitors, he shows hyper-attachment behavior towards Glicinia whom reports also signs of separation anxiety when she is not home or does not pay attention to him (scratching doors, chewing, urinating in the house and barking).
Medical History
Deaf
Vasectomized at 6 years old
Training
Hand signals training: Go, sit, stay, down, come
Using food rewards and petting
Diagnostic Plan
General exam
Basic neurological exam
Thyroid Panel
Routine hematology and biochemistry profile
Urinalysis
No remarkable findings
Behavioral Diagnosis
Competitive aggression towards the male owner
Protective aggression of the female owner
Anxiety related aggression
Other related diagnosis during clinical history
Hyper-attachment to female owner with signs of separation anxiety
Generalized anxiety probably due to deafness and inconsistent handling
Goals for the treatment plan
Provide safety and confidence to the owners in every day life
Establish a proper social relationship between dog and owners
Create a reliable and consistent lifestyle for Dios
Have more obedience control with hand signals commands
Work on the hyper attachment behavior
Treatment Plan
Castration
Avoid situations in which Dios is able to display aggression, or situations where Dios has shown aggression before
No punishment, No confrontation
Provide a consistent and predictable lifestyle for Dios
Use of a Gentle Leader® and indoor remote control leash
Increase exercise and create routines
Avoid letting Dios to sleep or rest at valuable places such as bed, sofa or door entrances
Practice obedience commands with hand signals using food as a reinforcer, particularly the male owner
Affection/Food control program (NILIF) Using obedience hand signals commands and calm behaviors in order to get anything Dios wants
Lower Social interaction with female owner
Avoid any kind of competitive play
Ignore all attention demands initiated by Dios
Reward independent, calm and submissive behaviors
DS & CC to departures using graduated planned departures with a safety cue
Fluoxetine 30 mg every 24h PO
References
1. Askew HR. Treatment of behavior problems in dogs and cats: A guide for the small animal veterinarian: Iowa State; 1998
2. Beaver B. Dog bite prevention, Proceedings of the 138 Th AVMA convention; July 2001 Boston, MA
3. Fogle B. l The dog's mind: Understanding your dog's behavior: Howell Bookhouse; 1990
4. Manteca X. Difficulties in the diagnosis of dominance aggression in dogs, Proceedings of the 27th. WSAVA congress
5. Overall K. Clinical behavioral medicine for small animals: Mosby; 1997
6. Simpson B. Update on behavioral drugs, Proceedings of the 138 Th AVMA convention-2001 Boston, MA